Publié le 16 novembre 2026 · 5 min read
For this week’s Reality Cheque column, we’re looking at the money myth that you can’t return food to the grocery store.
Few things are as disappointing or frustrating as coming back from the grocery store only to discover strawberries harbouring a mouldy infiltrator, a slimy boxed salad, or the chicken smelling off.
We’ve all been there. Some of us jump back in our cars and ask for a return. Likely more of us figuratively eat the cost. Which leads us to ask: What are Canadian grocery stores willing to do for dissatisfied customers, and what can you do to get your money’s worth?
To get some industry perspective, I invited the Retail Council of Canada and the Canadian Produce Marketing Association to weigh in. Both redirected me to connect with Canadian grocers; it seems the best insights are found closer to the produce aisle. Savvy shopping!
Can you return food to the grocery store?
Yes, just ask my husband Mario. He’s our home’s primary grocery shopper. After the second time he brought home fruit that was spoiled at the very bottom of its little carton, making it nearly impossible to detect, he drove back to the grocery store. The store manager (at Sobeys) was incredibly understanding.
Here’s what she did for Mario: She took the spoiled produce back and gave him a gift card for future purchases to cover the cost, plus a replacement (basically, the item’s price doubled). He felt this was excellent customer service, given his time, gas money and energy.
For Toronto-based chef and food stylist Rossy Earle, returning groceries is sometimes part of the job. Recipe development and food shoots can mean buying large quantities of ingredients, often on a strict budget. She has returned salmon that smelled off when she opened the package the next day, bread with mould that wasn’t visible at purchase, and corn with damaged, decayed kernels beneath the husks. And she explains, “Sometimes recipes or projects get scrapped, and you don’t need to use 15 cans of evaporated milk. If I keep them, then they come out of my pocket.”
Earle says she’s never had trouble getting a refund or replacement when she had a valid reason and a receipt. She’s returned items to several retailers, including Loblaws, No Frills, Costco and Toronto independent stores like Fiesta Farms and Harvest Wagon.
For her, the effort comes down to the cost of the groceries, the time involved and how far she has to travel. “As for personal use, groceries are very expensive these days, and while I am a very savvy shopper, on occasion the perishables can perish too soon. For example, I won’t drive out of my way to a store to return a dying green pepper that cost me $1.25, but I will walk the two minutes to the No Frills by my home to return and exchange one that literally went bad overnight, as happened a couple of days ago,” says Earle.“On another occasion, I did drive 20 minutes back to a store the following day to return $30 worth of white asparagus that had turned to mush overnight.”
Her advice: Know the store’s policy, keep your receipt and politely explain the problem. And remember, a reasonable return for food that has spoiled prematurely is one thing; forgetting about groceries in the back of the fridge for a week is quite another.
Guarantees by Canadian national grocers
Here’s the skinny on what national Canadian grocers will and won’t do for you if you buy mouldy produce, or, in my case, a puff pastry roll flecked with a flurry of fruit flies.
Most Canadian grocers offer some guarantees and will refund or replace your item within reason, usually within three to 14 days of purchase, when you have a receipt. This usually covers items that are spoiled or mouldy, defective, expired, not as ordered (e.g., prepared foods), or have a food quality problem. However, if you bought a perfectly good package of crackers and decided you don’t like the taste, that’s a different matter.
Return and refund eligibility depends on the store’s policy, applicable provincial or territorial consumer-protection laws, and the circumstances of the complaint. Check the store’s FAQs page on its website, and the laws on your province’s or territory’s website.
Know though, that a store’s freshness guarantee doesn’t give you a general legal right to return something simply because you changed your mind. In other words, the rules aren’t necessarily about whether you like the food; they’re about whether the retailer’s promise covers the reason you’re unhappy.
If you buy too much of something, do as Earle did: She ensured the unused cans were unopened, she presented her receipt at the customer service desk, and she received a full refund.
Buyer beware, though, if you shop sales. There are often restrictions on returning discounted, clearance and limited-time-offer products, expired products, alcohol and other excluded categories like pharmacy items. And many grocers won’t give a refund on products you purchased on “buy one get one free” offers, or bought with an in-store promotion.
Grocery store return policies in Canada
Here’s what you should know when you’re returning a packaged good or fresh food item to one of Canada’s major grocery stores, as of press time. Scroll to the right to see the full table.
| Grocer and banner stores | Return policy | Get more info |
|---|---|---|
Sobeys, FreshCo, Safeway, Foodland | The “100% Fresh Guarantee” applies storewide to eligible purchases: If a food purchase doesn’t meet your expectations, when prepared or consumed as intended, you can present the product and/or the receipt, and Sobeys says it will refund the purchase price. No receipt? You may get a gift card. Sobeys also has a separate 14-day, receipt-required guarantee for its Compliments private label. | |
Loblaws, No Frills, Real Canadian Superstore, Zehrs | The “Fresh Promise” means that if you’re not completely satisfied, you can bring the food back to the store you bought it from, within seven days, for a replacement with an identical or comparable item and refund the purchase price. This doesn’t apply to reduced or clearance-priced produce. | |
Costco | Its Canadian policy guarantees Costco members’ satisfaction with every item it sells, subject to a relatively short list of exceptions, not including food. You can return the food to any warehouse; the original receipt and packaging are preferred but not necessarily required. | |
Metro, Super C, Food Basics, Adonis, Première Moisson | Metro’s Freshness Guarantee covers a wide range of fresh foods, including fruits and vegetables, meat and poultry, fish and seafood, bakery, dairy and eggs, deli and prepared meals. You have three days and must bring the product and original receipt; the product must not have been consumed or expired. Metro says it will refund the purchase price plus 10% as a credit toward a future purchase. Dry goods and frozen foods aren’t covered. | |
Save-On-Foods, Buy-Low Foods, Quality Foods, Choices Markets, PriceSmart Foods, Nesters Market, Urban Fare | These Western Canada grocers offer a “Produce Promise” that allows customers to return unsatisfactory fresh produce within 14 days, with the original receipt and a More Rewards card. Customers receive a refund, replacement produce up to the original purchase price, plus 500 More Rewards points per qualifying transaction. |
Read more from this issue of The Get:

Mary Luz Mejia
Mary Luz Mejia is a freelance journalist, food and travel writer and Canada’s first IICCT Level III Certified Chocolate Taster.
The Get is owned by Neo Financial Technologies Inc. and the content it produces is for informational purposes only. Any views and opinions expressed are those of the individual authors or The Get editorial team and do not necessarily reflect the official policy or position of Neo Financial Technologies Inc. or any of its partners or affiliates.
Nothing in this newsletter is intended to constitute professional financial, legal, or tax advice, and should not be the sole source for making any financial decisions. Past performance is not a guarantee of future results. Neo Financial Technologies Inc. does not endorse any third-party views referenced in this content. Always do your due diligence before deciding what to do with your money.
© 2026 Neo Financial Technologies Inc. All rights reserved.





